The 2024 MLB season was full of surprises for New York baseball fans, but not in the way many expected. The New York Mets, who struggled early on, turned things around in the second half, catching fire just in time for a thrilling postseason run. Star performances from Pete Alonso and Francisco Lindor led the charge, while clutch pitching helped the Mets secure a Wild Card spot. As the playoffs progressed, their underdog status did not stop them from defeating high-ranking teams, proving they were serious contenders. Fans were thrilled to see the Mets fighting hard, showing resilience, and making deep progress in October.

Meanwhile, across town, the Yankees fell short of expectations, losing the first three games in the World Series. Despite Aaron Judge’s dominant season and promising pitching from Gerrit Cole, the Yankees could not overcome inconsistent performances and key injuries. Fans who expected another championship run were left disappointed as the Bronx Bombers never quite found their groove, and the season ended in frustration. While Mets fans celebrated, Yankees fans were left wondering what went wrong and what changes might be on the way for the offseason. For New York baseball, 2024 was a year of excitement and disappointment—depending on which team you root for.